7 Comments
User's avatar
Brye Steeves's avatar

I choose practical optimism!

Expand full comment
Stephanie Nakhleh's avatar

Two of us for Team Practical Optimism! Our motto can be, "Probably we're not all going to die tomorrow so let's get to work."

Expand full comment
Katy Korkos's avatar

I love this. Do you follow Rebecca Solnit? Her writing on hope is useful

Expand full comment
Stephanie Nakhleh's avatar

I love her! I cited her when I first started noodling on this article (I posted a predecessor to this piece on Facebook weeks ago), but then I forgot to include her in the final piece.

Expand full comment
BeaverInChicago's avatar

I needed to hear this today.

Expand full comment
James R (Randy) Fromm's avatar

Greatly enjoyed this piece. I came across a similar argument recently, albeit through a different disciplinary approach. You might enjoy reading it. The author, John Plotz, is a Victorianist with political side interests and what he and others call ‘B side’ texts, those texts ‘lost’ to readers because other, ‘bigger’ texts get all of the attention. His term for ‘doomerism’ is ‘anticipatory despair’, riffing on Timothy Snyder’s notion of ‘anticipatory obedience’. I do, though, really like ‘Futilitarianism’. Thank you for introducing me to that term.

Here’s a link to Plotz’ short ‘essay’: https://www.publicbooks.org/lying-in-politics-hannah-arendts-antidote-to-anticipatory-despair/

Expand full comment
Luca Gattoni-Celli's avatar

lol

Expand full comment