Share from 0:00
0:00
/

NM Leg 2026 - Housing policy in 30 days

Johanna Gilligan and Daniel Werwath on starter homes, data transparency, and Friday’s big defeat

Thank you Jeff Fong, Benjamin Hill, David Hampton, and many others for tuning into my live video with Johanna Gilligan and Daniel Werwath! Join me for my next live video in the app.

Get more from Stephanie Nakhleh in the Substack app
Available for iOS and Android

With New Mexico’s 30-day legislative session halfway done, many housing bills haven’t even been scheduled, which does not bode especially well for progress on this urgent issue. However, two housing bills with legs, both from the affordable-housing nonprofit Homewise, are scheduled for this week. To hear more about those, I asked Homewise president Johanna Gilligan and housing policy analyst Daniel Werwath to join me on my weekly legislative livestream. Daniel and I also discussed what happened on Friday, when one of the session’s most closely watched zoning reform proposals was killed in committee.


HB 200: Starter-home subsidy

[1:20 - 12:50]

Gilligan opened with HB 200, the “New Homes for New Mexico” bill heard Monday afternoon in the House Commerce & Economic Development Committee. The proposal, supported by Homewise, offers $50,000 subsidies to eligible buyers in most markets and $75,000 in high-cost municipalities such as Los Alamos, Santa Fe, and Taos. The subsidy would apply to newly built starter homes under 1,800 square feet on lots of 5,000 square feet or less.

The assistance is a zero-interest deferred loan repaid when the home is sold or no longer serves as the buyer’s primary residence. The funds then recycle to future buyers, what Gilligan described as an “evergreen funding tool,” rather than a one-time appropriation.

The bill targets a housing type that has nearly disappeared. “Used to be 40% of the market nationally, but by 2023 it’s just 12%,” said Gilligan of starter homes. “And if you look at the stats in a place like Albuquerque, it’s even less. These days, it’s about 4% of homes that are designed as smaller homes, starter homes.”

Why demand-side assistance could unlock supply

Gilligan explained that the subsidy, which goes straight to the buyer, aims to make mixed projects financially viable.1 A builder might include 10 starter homes in a 50-unit project, knowing “these homes may not be my highest margin home,” she said, but confident they’ll “be able to sell the home because of this subsidy.”

Why does that matter? Because in many markets, median prices for existing homes fall below the cost of new construction, removing the financial case for building entry-level housing without some form of buyer assistance.

Española’s lot-size constraint

Participating municipalities would need to allow homes on lots of 5,000 square feet or less. I asked what happens when local zoning makes that impossible. (See this Strong Towns’ piece on why legalizing small minimum lot sizes is such an important affordability tool.) Gilligan pointed to Española’s 7,500-square-foot minimum lot size, which has blocked Homewise projects despite local interest in change.

“Municipalities would need to make sure that you could build a home on 5,000 square feet or less,” Gilligan said, “which we hope would incentivize change to some of the minimum lot sizes in smaller and more rural towns.”

Multiple returns on one intervention

Werwath described HB 200 as a policy that addresses several constraints at once. “You get a development subsidy, a consumer down-payment assistance subsidy, and in most cases, you’re also freeing up a rental unit,” he said. (He is referring to a phenomenon called “filtering,” where new supply helps free up housing on the more affordable end of the market.)

He also pointed to the fiscal return. “We’ll get half of that money back in gross receipts tax,” he said, arguing that the bill makes unusually efficient use of state funds.

At the same time, Werwath cautioned that demand-side assistance alone can make affordability worse if supply remains constrained.2 He traced the current housing shortage to post-Great Recession underbuilding, compounded by pandemic-era demand.3

Note: HB 200 passed the House Commerce & Economic Development Committee Monday afternoon on a 9–1 vote.


HB 110: Housing data transparency

[12:50–26:22]

The discussion then turned to HB 110, another Homewise-backed bill. The proposal would require New Mexico’s seven largest cities to publish quarterly data on housing applications and permits, including approval rates and processing timelines. The bill is scheduled for Tuesday, Feb. 3, at 9 a.m. in the House Rural Development, Land Grants and Cultural Affairs Committee.

(For my subscribers who may be reading this hot-off-the-presses newsletter blearily over their first cup of coffee: that’s today.)

Gilligan framed the bill as a baseline fact-finding exercise. The goal is to track applications for projects over four units and all building permits in order “to understand how much housing are we producing in the seven largest cities in the state? And how quickly is that getting done? And how does that compare across municipalities?”

“We do housing mostly on vibes”

The bill aims to address a persistent problem: nobody is systematically collecting this data. Without it, everyone is guessing, and evidence gaps get filled by ideology. Or, as Werwath put it: “We do housing mostly on vibes in New Mexico.”

An example is HB 17, the ADU reform bill that died in committee Friday. “We don’t have data to show what’s needed, what is working, who’s doing well, who isn’t,” said Werewath.

The differences across jurisdictions are substantial. Santa Fe County’s multi-year approval timelines for large projects can add as much as $80,000 per unit, costs ultimately borne by renters and buyers. By contrast, Las Cruces issues building permits in one to two weeks, Werwath said. Rio Rancho now accounts for roughly 75% of new home construction in the Albuquerque metro area, in part because Albuquerque’s approval process takes longer.

“Are communities adding enough housing to meet demand? Are they adding the right type of housing?” Werwath asked. “Without this data, we can’t compare.”

What actually causes delays?

Gilligan said that not all delays originate with local governments. “Not every delay is caused by the city,” she said. “Developers delay, too. That’s really important to acknowledge.”

For that reason, the bill defines the start of the review clock as the point when an application is deemed complete, rather than when it is first submitted. That avoids penalizing cities for delays tied to missing engineering plans or incomplete materials.

Permitting remains one of the lowest-cost areas for improvement. In many cases, delays stem from staffing shortages or outdated processes. Santa Fe, for example, has worked for years to move away from physical permit sets but still relies on hard-copy reviews, an administrative choice that adds time without improving outcomes.

Municipal League opposition

Despite support from several cities, the New Mexico Municipal League opposes HB 110. Gilligan attributed that opposition to a) the Municipal League’s allergy to anything that smacks of state preemption and b) a misunderstanding of the bill’s scope. “This is not a preemption bill,” she said. The proposal does not dictate how cities run permitting systems. It makes baseline data public.

The bill includes no enforcement mechanism. The information would become public record and subject to IPRA requests. Cities that support the measure say they already collect most of the required data.

Gilligan also cited recent YouGov polling showing that more than 65% of respondents prioritized building more housing over preserving local government control.


Local control, and its limits

[26:22]

Werwath argued that housing reforms often get mislabeled as “preemption.” Land-use authority, he said, flows from the state and remains conditional. Local control is therefore “a privilege, not a right.”

When approval processes allow small groups to block housing needed by the broader community, he said, state intervention becomes a legitimate option. The Municipal League, he argued, “is not out for the best interest of their communities… They’re out to preserve the maximal interpretation of local government power under the framework of state law, regardless of whether that serves their communities.”


Regional spillovers

[28:46]

Housing shortages do not stop at jurisdictional boundaries. Werwath pointed to Los Alamos as a clear example. “You have huge job growth,” he said. “You’re hiring tons of people, but you’re not building any housing.”

The result is displacement pressure that cascades outward, from Los Alamos to Santa Fe and then to Albuquerque, turning local housing decisions into statewide consequences.


Friday’s surprise: HB 17 fails, 8–2

[34:56]

The session’s most significant housing setback came Friday, when Rep. Andrea Romero’s HB 17 died in the House Commerce & Economic Development Committee. A nearly identical ADU and multifamily standardization bill passed the House 50–10 last year with bipartisan support.

Werwath cited several factors. The bill paired ADU legalization with transit-oriented development exemptions, increasing the number of objections legislators could raise. More importantly, he said, the New Mexico Municipal League mounted an organized campaign, while advocates lacked the coordinated groundwork present last year, when housing specialists staffed the governor’s office. Many legislators entered the hearing with little advance briefing.

Opponents again raised concerns about traffic and infrastructure capacity, arguments Werwath said lack evidentiary support.

A too-narrow coalition?

[37:36]

Support for HB 17 came primarily from business groups, including the Greater Albuquerque Chamber of Commerce and homebuilders, rather than from a broader civic coalition. Werwath contrasted that with Santa Fe’s 2019 ADU reform effort, which included nonprofits serving domestic violence survivors that sought to expand housing options through accessory dwelling units.


Persistent skepticism about supply

[40:20]

Despite national momentum behind supply-side reforms, Werwath said New Mexico remains wedded to older frameworks. “Many local structures still operate on a 1990s model of housing policy, subsidy-based and income-restricted, while the underlying supply shortage continues to drive prices,” he said. (I wrote a piece on supply skepticism a few months ago with more on this eternal debate.)


What comes next

[41:40]

HB 200 passed the House Commerce & Economic Development Committee on Monday. HB 110 will be heard Tuesday, Feb. 3, at 9 a.m. in Room 305.

Senate Bill 131, a major zoning reform package sponsored by Sen. Antonio “Moe” Maestas, faces uncertain prospects. No housing bills have yet received Senate hearings, and the relevant committee chair, Sen. Linda Lopez, has centered recent debate on rent control. Rent control and related ideological divides will be taken up at the Monday, Feb. 9 livestream.

Werwath offered a guarded assessment. “I’m not optimistic about zoning reform this session. But without data, we can’t make a credible case for why reform matters.”

Committee schedules and Zoom links are available at nmlegis.gov. Ongoing updates and analysis continue on We Can Have Nice Things.

1

Viewers may notice that I muddied the waters by asking an irrelevant question about builders—they do not receive this subsidy.

2

This is a basic finding in economics: if you subsidize demand without increasing supply in a market where supply is relatively fixed, the main effect is a price increase, which accrues to owners of the limited good—in housing’s case, landlords or property owners. Here’s a study illustrating how this happens in real life.

3

If anyone wants to nerd out on the Great Recession and housing, I recommend Kevin Erdmann’s hot takes such as “The Great Recession Was Caused By Mortgage Suppression.”

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?